Liar, Liar

The first time our daughter, 16 months old, said, “Eyes hurt,” I had just put her in the car seat after a trip to the beach. I wiped her face gently, and hoped I hadn’t gotten lotion in her eye. Then she said, “Eyes hurt,” on the changing table one evening, and I said, “Are you tired? Yeah, me, too.”

I’m thrilled at how she’s become an effective communicator. She says, “Bump,” when she bumps her head, which is a few times a day. Children her age are so active and so clumsy, my friends and I compare injuries when we get together. This one has a fat lip from falling on her face; that one has mosquito bites all over; a third scraped his tush running around the yard naked.

Only recently did my husband and I realize that our daughter will say “Hurt, hurt,” when she doesn’t want to do something—like wear a bib to eat, or read the last book before bed. She’s especially resistant to being put in the car seat, only for a minute, and then she enjoys the ride (usually to someplace fun and exciting for her). She’s actually faking it. She’s lying.

Where did this hypochondria arise from? When did it occur to her to lie or trick us into giving her sympathy? I’m sure this behavior is common for toddlers, but I’m surprised by its spontaneous appearance. Sure, she’s a ham. You can see her acting sometimes. She’ll toss her head around in funny ways to get a laugh, and also become super affectionate sometimes, walking over and kissing us on the leg or arm, and melting us to puddles.  So, while we’re doing some necessary chores that she may not want to do, she says, “Head. Bump. Hurt. Hurt.” But it’s not real! She’ll say “Eyes. Eyes. Hurt.” Sometimes she’ll cycle through them all. When I start pouring water on her head in the bath, she’ll say, “Hot. Hot.” Even though it’s not too hot.

The question is, where did she get the idea to fake us out and try to manipulate us? She’s not even a year and a half old. And how should we respond? The first few times, I actually worried her eyes were hurting, so I tried my best to soothe her. But now she’s crying wolf. One thought is to honor her words, and soothe her when she says these things, and let her live with the truth. But usually we say, “You’re fine,” or “Come on, that’s not true.” Maybe I’ll say, “Let me see your eyes. They look fine to me,” so in part I’m validating her claim, and also teaching her that I can see nothing’s wrong.

I’ll have to ask my mother if I pulled this schtick when I was little. As parents of a toddler who isn’t in daycare, we assume almost all her behavior stems from us. So, whenever her behavior baffles us, we look to ourselves to understand how we may have cultured it.

Aha! We also marvel at her blonde hair and blue eyes, neither of which resembles our own features. So maybe hypochondria, too, is a recessive trait, that comes from the grandparents? That must be it.

About MommyTheorist

Editor, writer, photographer, and new mom
This entry was posted in Family, Marriage, Parenting, Psychology and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Liar, Liar

  1. Lynda says:

    Are you implying there are hypochondriacs in your family :-) ?

  2. Ida says:

    I’m not so sure they know the true meaning of the words they say yet, just the response they will get when they say them. So when she says “hurt” and you respond by stopping and checking on her or lovingly stroking her head, that’s what she wants to happen again. So does she really know what “hot” means, or does she know that if she says “hot” you will stop pouring water on her head? Either way, her language skills sound superb!

  3. becca says:

    They’re all liars and attention-freaks. Mine throws himself on the floor and bangs his head for attention. He’s a sadist and a masochist b/c it hurts me to see him do that. I think he knows…

  4. Say says:

    i dont think she is lying. at all.
    we as adults perceive that its lying when in fact it can be a lack of vocabulary. she is not manipulating you. and when she uses words that she knows that get your attention/reacction she is not lying, but rather using those words as a tool to get you to react.
    maybe the word “hurt” when used with the seatbelt actually means “unconfortable”, but i have yet to see a 5 year old pronounce it or use it right

  5. oliarights says:

    So funny! Isaiah lies too. He climbs out of his crib and says, “I slept” When I know he didn’t, he was just jumping for 5 minutes on the monitor.
    I heard a story on the radio about how young kids start lying. It is really early in our lives :)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s